There was a time when things were very predictable. In either television or comics, the heroes always overcame the villains. Sure, there were some tense moments, and you might even have held your breath during a cliffhanger when it seems that evil might triumph in the end after all. But there was always this nagging voice in your head that told you things would be fine. And they always were. When you look at television and modern media things sure have changed. Where in the old days character deaths were unheard of, especially the ones that had been around for years, nowadays things aren’t so predictable anymore. Hell, look at shows such as The Walking Dead or Game Of Thrones where not even the actors themselves were sure if they would still have a job the next day. I think it’s something that has made things much more interesting. It really ups the tension when you aren’t sure that your heroes might survive an ordeal. In comic books recent years have shown us, that things have changed there as well. No longer are heroes so sure of the fact that they will be saving the day, much less come out alive. Many famous characters have all died at some point (and have miraculously been resurrected as well) and usually that resulted in a very thrilling and tense story.

In 1988, it was the 50th anniversary of one of the most famous characters in comic book history: Batman. Unless you have been living under a rock, it’s someone who needs no introduction, nor does his sidekick Robin. In order to do something special to mark this momentous occasion, DC comics gave readers one of the most creative influences they would ever have on a story, by giving them a choice. A very simple one at that. For years Batman and Robin had been a Dynamic Duo and were inseparable. Whether that would remain that way, was going to depend on what the readers eventually decided. When the comic came out, and was given the title A Death in the Family, I think it becomes clear which choice was made. Continuing my journey into DC comics that I started with DCeased this time I went back into the past, to read a story that had always left me intrigued, but that I never experienced fully. I was twelve years old at the time of this release. I did flip through the pages of this book in the store back then, and was actually shocked they would kill off such a well known character. But I never read the full story, until now that is. This collection contains the original four part story of A death in the family, as well as the five part A Lonely Place of Dying that would introduce a new Robin.

So aside from the fact that this is of course a landmark event when it comes to the world of comics, is this is a story that is worth your time, or spending your hard earned cash on so to speak. I can only say that without a doubt it very much is. In A Death in the Family we have Batman again taking on his arch nemesis The Joker who has just escaped from Arkham prison. As if this weren’t enough to keep the Bats busy, we also have Robin going through a crisis of a much more personal nature. Having recently found out that his mother who has died, shockingly wasn’t his real mother, he begins a quest to find out the whereabouts of the woman who really gave birth to him. The boy recently had a falling out with Batman, who accused him of being too emotionally involved in fighting criminals since the death of his parents. As such he has ample time to go on a search for her, a path that will eventually lead him to the Middle East. Little does he know that Batman who is trying to track down the Joker is also heading there. Eventually their paths will cross, and both heroes will have to combine their forces if they are to stop the nefarious plans of the criminal mastermind. However this time, things might not end up so well for one of them….

To say this was one heck of phenomenal read, is probably the understatement of the year. A Death in the Family was a highly emotional rollercoaster from start to finish. It addresses quite a number of issues, but I was also very surprised at how mature this comic book felt. At one side we have Robin’s quest for his real mother. To make it clear, this isn’t the original Robin that Batman started out with, but a second one called Jason Todd, who filled the original’s shoes when he left Batman’s side. I found his arc to be incredibly well handled in this book. Since both his parents had died, the hope that shone in his eyes when he finds out his real mother might still be alive is heartbreaking, especially knowing what’s going to happen to him in this book. Whether or not he eventually finds her, I will leave for you to discover. Hey, can’t give away everything now can I? But Batman’s struggle is also terrific as he faces off with his arch nemesis. For years Batman has kept his emotions in check when it comes to killing off his enemies, and even as heinous as the crimes of The Joker have been throughout the years, he has never crossed the line by taking his life. Seeing as The Joker is simply put, totally insane, and not fully in control of himself.

Here though Batman realises that to stop his reign of terror he might have to do just that. It’s really fascinating to see how Batman struggles with this throughout the entire four chapter arc. As the story dates back to 1988 I was also surprised to have them include the powder keg that was Iran during those days. We even see Khomeini himself encounter the Joker, once again demonstrating the matureness of this storyline. The art that accompanies the story is also very good, even though it’s now over 30 years old. The second story contained in this volume was also terrific, though not as powerful as the first one. In this we see a Batman who has become reckless after losing his friend and partner, and in this way puts himself in ever more dangerous situations. The criminal Two Face wants to once and for all take Batman out, something he might succeed at seeing how conflicted the Dark Knight has become. It also introduces the world to a character who will eventually become the new Robin. This collection was an incredible read, and it’s one that can be read by everyone, even if you aren’t really familiar with the world of Batman.
I give a Death in the Family a 9 out of 10 score.

Is it too late to vote for Robin to be killed? How did they ensure a fair vote? Did DC observers stand ten feet away from the count? And if Robin is dead, will they stop the count?
LikeLiked by 2 people
Lol😂 Well…seeing as this comic dates back to 1988 I’m probably quite sure that the lines for this one have closed😂 That said, you can always try of course😊😊
But yep Robin did kick the bucket here so to speak…then again, he already is back in the land of the living, or so I hear. I’m trying to get more knowledge about the DC universe, so who knows I might explore that story next time 😊
LikeLike
I get a bit fed up of all the hoopla about characters dying in comic books, they always come back, don’t they?
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yeah, most of them do I guess😊 I don’t think anyone ever really died, and stayed dead. This story though is different, as it was made by the readers, and it took quite a while for him to eventually make a real comeback. (and I don’t even know how that was done….yet🤔🤔)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Maybe it’s a hangover from the Marvel Infinity War for me, but I can’t muster tears for characters that can be brought back with a snap of fingers…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well…to be fair, not all of them made it: Black Widow really is dead. (The upcoming film is after all a prequel) and so is the daughter of Thanos, Gamora. Wolverine has also died in the Marvel cinematic universe, so yeah there are real deaths there😊
You are right though..in comics a lot of so called “deaths” aren’t real. But eh, this story was very good though, and I liked how it played out 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Is this why they never put Robin in the Batman movies?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good question🤔 Batman always was a bit more of a solo styled hero I guess…But I’ve never been really familiair with the DC Universe as much as Marvel, but I’m trying to play some catch up (which is all Lashaan’s fault as he does an amazing job in promoting these comics! 😂😂😂)
LikeLiked by 1 person
I used to like Robin in the original TV series when Adam West was Batman. Just realised there was one Batman and Robin movie back in 1997 George Clooney was Batman and Chris O Donnell was Robin.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well…even in the final Christopher Nolan film, Robin made an appearance at the end (well..at least it seemed to play out that way).
The original adam west series really was a lot of fun. Very campy, but also highly enjoyable. I used to love it when I was a kid😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Me too, loved the KAPOW’s when he punched people 😀 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha…yeah, that was so cool, and who can forget the themesong! 😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I actually don’t think I have read this one! I need to change that right away. I recognise some of the story elements so I’m a little confused ha Have you read The Cult? Another Batman classic. Great read as usual.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Because of Lashaan’s blog, and his enthusiasm for all things DC I am slowly diving into these comics, as honestly I’m not too familiar with this universe. I was always more of a Marvel fan but lately I’m really enjoying the (much darker) tales of DC. This one is a comic I remember seeing when I was a kid in the bookstore, but I never was able to read it. I’m glad now, many year later I have still been able to enjoy it. It’s definitely worth checking out.
I haven’t yet read the Cult, but thanks for the recommendation, I’m immediately adding it to my to read list! 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
I enjoy Batman but I’m going to read The Swamp Thing Graphic Novels next year sometime and review them. Glad you are enjoying the DC universe.
LikeLike
Ooh, that’s something that I will definitely looking forward to then! That sounds really great! 😊😊
LikeLike
This sounds like a particularly complex and emotional chapter in the Batman universe. Great review Michel. I wish I could get my hands on it.
LikeLike
It really was, it’s definitely one of those really classic must read kind of tales. I highly enjoyed it, and at times forgot I was reading a comic book. I think it should be available on amazon😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Perhaps the success of this story led to the 1992/93 story The Death of Superman, which frankly I never took seriously. To kill a sidekick was one thing, to kill an iconic superhero was another.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It could be, although what I heard about that one back in the day was the fact that sales for the comic were declining, which is why they decided to kill him (The trick worked as sales skyrocketed 😊) That was a pretty good comic by the way!😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
I never knew that Robin had died! To be honest, i think it was really cool that readers voted to kill him off, as I always though he was unnecessary. I also suspect that the phone numbers given might have been premium rate numbers, so that DC made a healthy profit out of whatever was decided. 🙂
Best wishes, Pete.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha, well technically, as mentioned this is the second Robin😊 So, the original Robin was still alive in this comic😊 But yeah, it was a pretty horrible death too😊
I definitely think that they certainly made a profit out of this one, can’t be any other way. Then again, I do have to say that it’s a pretty nifty idea to let readers decide something like this😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
I take it back. I have not read this. I read the New 52 version of this, I believe.
Glad to see you enjoyed it 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah yes, the New 52…another thing I need to get into at some point😅😅 I feel like I need to do a lot of catching up😂😂
But yes, this was a great story, and I’m very happy that I finally got to read it in it’s entirety😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
This was a fantastic read when I read it on my Robin Journey a couple of years ago. I always thought of Tim Drake as Robin, so seeing how whiny Jason Todd was made me glad he was off’d.
Of course, it pissed me off to no end that he came back decades later as Red Hood. I still don’t understand fully how that took place. I even read Under the Red Hood and I’m still kind of confused.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha, whiny Jason Todd huh? 😂😂 Well,I of course only “met” him by this comic, so can’t really say much about his whiny behaviour, but at least here I found him to be quite the tragic hero. At least he “died” a hero😊
As for his resurection, in looking up new things to read, I found that he did indeed return, but I wasn’t even aware of that up until that point😊 I’m what you could consider a noob when it comes to DC, so I recently bought something that should help me in upping my game. It should be here in December😊(It’s an encyclopedia for the DC universe😊). So, pretty sure I will eventually read up on Red Hood as well at some point.
This though, really was an excellent read and I enjoyed it very much😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad to hear you enjoyed this one. It’s funny comparing the art from old comics to more recent ones, how very different they sometimes look. I think this is one I heard about after it all happened.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It really is, isn’t it? 😊 I have to say that I love retro art😊 It’s also very interesting to see how comic stories/art have evolved in general. Where it used to be pretty non violent except for the occasional fisticuffs, these days the blood and gore are all over the place! 😊
I really did enjoy this comic quite a lot. It was a really wonderful read, and it was nice to finally read the full story after all these years😊
LikeLike
I would have had to call in for Robin to live. Even though I’m not really attached to Batman or Robin (although I liked the old Superman shorts when I was younger), I’m such a softie. But at least the comic is good!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha…I know what you mean. I probably would have done so myself as well 😂 It’s a crazy concept, but really fun idea (even though of course this is pure marketing genius) It really was a terrific story, and one that I enjoyed a lot!😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Really happy to see how much you enjoyed this classic story-arc, my friend! I was also surprised by how his death came to be back then. I can’t imagine if DC decided to repeat such an experiment today for any character hahaha I have to say that I found Jason Todd here so frustrating from start to finish. It was still interesting to see what he went on to do. I also found it so odd yet somewhat fun when they exited Gotham and went full-on international! Who would’ve thought, right? Hahahah Joker’s disguise in that final act was so unexpected. 😛 And the introduction to the next Robin was also fascinating. Some could even call it blackmail, just to get the job as Robin! 😀 Again, I’m glad that you got around to reading this bad boy and I can’t wait to see where you’ll go next! I’d recommend Under the Red Hood as a next read following this one just so you have the “full” evolution of this story. 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha, well as I just said to someone else: it was pure marketing genius really! They probably made quite a lot of money with all those phonecalls😂😂
I’ve not come to know Jason Todd as much: only with this comic of course, but at least here I didn’t find him so frustrating. I kind of got his arc and his feelings here. The international route really was surprising, especially considering the countries the story eventually took place in. Those were really surprising (and daring) places to visit.
All in all, this was a really great collection. I’m going to visit a comic recommended by you, but I’m not telling which one……yet 😊 Gotta keep some secrets right? 😂
I’ll be adding Under the Red Hood to my list, thanks for the suggestion and of course another awesome comment!😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
One of the top Batman storylines of all time. Next to the Killing Joke and the Dark Knight Returns. Although I’ve yet to read it, I do have it on my list. Have you ever seen the 2010 animated adaptation Batman: Under the Red Hood? It’s one of the best DC animated movies.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Killing Joke I haven’t read yet, but I have seen the animated film for it. Which wasn’t bad, but I also heard that it failed to capture how good the comic was.
As for Under the Red Hood…no haven’t seen that one yet, but it’s also one of the comics that are on my to read list, and I want to do that first before I watch the film. That said, thanks for the recommendation, as I have now added that one to the list too😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
I wonder about the logistics of having a phone vote in a publication that has no real expiry date/shelf life thus is open to some corruption before the vote closes. It’s not like today where you can run a poll online, set a reasonable deadline and get immediate results. I’m assuming the story writers had two endings in mind and had to wait to see which one got the vote before it could be drawn?
LikeLiked by 1 person
They did have two versions ready to be published. In this collection there’s even a panel shown how the outcome would have been if Robin had not died.
I don’t know about the logistics either😅 It was an unprecented event back in those days, so you gotta give it that. And it was also quite a fun idea too😊 It didn’t turn out so well for Robin though……😂😂😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Unless Robin was really unpopular, I’d wager the result was never in doubt because the fans are morbidly cruel like that…. <_<
LikeLike
There seems to be a lot of confusion in the comments about whether Robin died, whether he came back, etc.
The first Robin was Dick Grayson. He grew up and took on the alter ego Nightwing to continue his crime fighting career.
The second Robin was Jason Todd. This is the character that the joker killed as the result of readers voting. Which I always felt was kind of sad. Maybe a more interesting story, but kind of sad all the same.
Jason Todd did make a sort of come back later on. His body was taken to a Lazarus Pit and he was brought back to life. However, he did not return to being Robin. He took on the alter Ego Red Hood.
A third Robin came along, Tim Drake he grew up too and took on the alter ego Red Robin.
And finally, the most recent/current Robin is Damian Wayne, Batman’s son with Talia al Ghul.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks for taking the time to clarify things and comment😊 I’m slowly getting into the DC universe myself (I was always more of a Marvel fan😂) But lately I’m really enjoying the DC universe a lot too😊
I hope to see thar resurection at some point, I’m certainly interested in it😊 Thanks again, this comment was great!😀
LikeLike
He died….but he got better! haha. Read Batman ‘Hush’ to learn more… 😉 honestly Hush is some of the finest Batman storytelling to come out in years. Takes this particular story to a whole new level.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha😊 That he did. I’m planning on getting that one as well, for the moment I have a few other titles I’m exploring both from Marvel and DC, but I have already got my eyes set on eventually reading that one as well 😊
LikeLike
I remembered reading the story a couple years ago. I bought the comics digital, but the story is pretty cool. I think it was cool how fans was able to choose Jason’s fate. I know DC recently released an interactive movie called A Death in Family. It’s basically Under the Red Hood, but you get to choose the path for Jason and Batman. I need to watch it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It really was a great story! It’s one I had wanted to read for a long while now, and I’m happy I finally got the chance for it!😊
I have heard that there was a movie released for it, but I didn’t know it was an interactive one. That sounds really interesting! Will try and see if I can watch it! 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
I might get the collection book one of these days. This story is pretty interesting. We get to see how much control did the fans had and how much it affected Batman.
Yep the movie is recent, but from I heard, you can choose the choices for the characters. If you enjoy Under the Hood, but the with ability to choose the path in the story, you should check it out. I might pick up the DVD 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Do you know that it was essentially one guy who killed Robin? They found out years later it was done tech operator who masked his phone number and voted x number of times for Robins death
LikeLike