Not every long running comic book series is about superheroes that fly around in their spandex costumes. Which is a good thing, because there is plenty more to enjoy than just these caped crusaders when it comes to stories that feature some type of hero. Take Judge Dredd for instance. Originating way back in 1977, this I guess you could call him anti-hero made it’s first appearance in the British comic book 2000 AD. The story of Judge Dredd takes place in a future where most of the Earth is an irradiated wasteland also known as The Scorched Earth. Mega City One is a huge metropolis that is home to more than 800 million people, and stretches out across most of the Eastern United States. As one would expect, with so many people living in close proximity to each other, this is powder keg where crime runs rampant. But that’s where the judges come in. Serving as the police, but also as judge, jury and executioner, these men and women enforce the law with an iron hand. The most feared amongst them is Judge Dredd. The mere mention of his name is enough to send criminals off to cower in a corner.

The comic was a huge succes and is still ongoing with an enormous amount of issues that have been published, as well as loads of sidestories that tell more about the characters in Dredd’s world. When something is a succes, it usually means that Hollywood comes knocking, and so it was when the movie Judge Dredd was released in 1995. Starring none other than Sylvester Stallone in the titular role, the film unfortunately wasn’t a big succes. Even though it had a huge budget, and it looked the part both in special effects and set decorations, it didn’t feel like it did erm justice to this dark hero. One of the biggest sins was the fact that Dredd took off his helmet that conceals most of his face, something that had never happened in the history of the comic. The film unsurprisingly never got a sequel, and even though it’s still campy fun in it’s own way, most fans of Dredd despise it. To everyone’s surprise though almost 20 years later a new movie was made, that was set up to serve as kind of a reboot. This time it starred actor Karl Urban in the lead role, and this movie could not be any more different from the 1995 incarnation. For one thing it’s R-rated, for another this is the film that should have been made in the first place as it truly brings to life the hard hitting character of Judge Dredd.

In Mega City One there is a new type of drug that is taking over the city by storm. Called Slo-Mo, it causes it’s users to perceive time as though it’s moving at 1% of it’s normal rate. In a huge 200 floor city block, three people have been found dead, skinned alive and thrown from the top floor of the building. Responding to the call is Judge Dredd, together with the female rookie recruit Anderson. She recently failed the judge aptitude test, but only by a very narrow margin. The reason she hasn’t yet been dismissed completely is the fact that she is a very powerful psychic, who is able to read people’s minds like a normal person would read a book. It’s up to Dredd to assess her abilities and see if she is up to the task of becoming a full on street judge. However the both of them have no idea what they are about to run into. Arriving at the scene, it doesn’t take them very long to find the killer, due in part to the mind reading abilities of Anderson. When they are about to leave with the perp in custody, the building goes into a lockdown, trapping the judges inside together with the citizens and criminals that call the building their home. A chilling voice soon comes over the P.A. system, belonging to the insane drug dealer Ma-Ma, and she calls out to everyone to kill the judges. In this impossible situation it seems the curtain has fallen for them both. But impossible isn’t in Dredd’s vocabulary….

Dredd is one of the most underrated movies ever made. When it was released critics were mostly very positive about it, but the public didn’t really go watch it. This might be in part because of the bad taste that the Stallone driven film left behind back in 1995. And that’s a real shame, as this movie really is incredibly good. A fact that more and more people are discovering, as the movie got a new life in home theatre releases and has since become a bit of a cult film. One of the things that makes this movie so good is Karl Urban’s performance. He simply IS Judge Dredd, and has a truly tough job, as in contrast to Stallone, Urban doesn’t take his helmet off, which means you can only see his mouth. He still manages to give life to his character though, and his Dirty Harry on steroids act is definitely the highlight of this film. Let’s not discount Olivia Thirlby’s role though as the vulnerable, but also heroic recruit Anderson. She is tough as nails, but also has a bit more of a human side to her, which is a nice counterbalance to Dredd’s “shoot first ask questions later” demeanor. Their onscreen chemistry, such as it is, really works well and as this movie mainly focusses on them, that’s a good thing.

Lena Headey, who most people will know from Game Of Thrones as the evil Queen Cersei, plays the main villain in Dredd, the loathsome Ma-Ma. With a horribly disfigured face, there is no humanity whatsoever left inside her. Even though it’s a really good performance, there is little to no background on her, which ultimately makes it a bit of a flat character. Dredd isn’t R-Rated for nothing, as there are a lot of violent scenes in this film. For martial arts fans that might have heard of a movie called The Raid, this film has quite a few similarities with that one. Dredd and Anderson must fight their way through floors and floors of criminals in order to stay alive. The camera style that’s being used is also worth noting as even though it’s a brutal film, it’s brought to life in an almost artful way with extensive use of slow motion (also in part caused by scenes where people are under the influence of the Slo-Mo drug). Dredd is an incredibly violent, actionpacked science fiction movie that’s well worth your time. Karl Urban himself has been game to reprise his role for many years now, and with an incredibly strong fan base that want to see this happen, we can only hope that it will. For now though, there is no law that’s keeping you from watching this film!
I give Dredd a 9 out of 10 score.

I watched this on TV about five years ago, and I really enjoyed it! I love it when they play such fantastical roles so straight and serious. Stallone was perfect for the part.
Best wishes, Pete.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah, but erm…this isn’t the Stallone version😅😅
This one is the much better version without Stallone but instead with Karl Urban as Dredd😅😅
LikeLiked by 1 person
Did I read the whole thing wrong? Christ! I must be losing it. I must have been reading what was in my mind, instead of what was on the page. Is that dementia starting? No wonder I need a blogging break!! So ignore that comment, because I watched the Stallone one, and thought it was okay. Checking myself into an old folk’s home tomorrow, as I can’t be trusted with being a blogger any longer!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha…no worries at all Pete. I’ve had that happen once too😊 The Stallone version certainly wasn’t bad at all, but I have the feeling that you will like this one much better, as it’s a much grittier and serious film (Which is what the comic is too😊).
So really no need to be hard on yourself at all!😊 But as I said, this is a cool film, and I’m pretty sure you will like it! 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
I just read it through again, and I have no idea how I missed the entire section mentioning it was a remake starring Urban. Genuinely worrying!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha….as I said, no problem, and it’s happened to me once or twice too when I read a post and completely misread something lol😊
But yes this version is a reboot, with a much better player as Dredd too 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
I liked this one a lot better then the Stalone version. That death at the end felt really satisfying and the partner dynamic was great! The part that vexes me a bit are the traitor Judges, that could have been done better. They do this weird act around each other and it doesn’t make much sense to me. Either the traitors could have gunned Dread and companion down from the get go or they should have been bought of later on or something. That did not work for me.. but for the rest this was a really good watch!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I know what you mean. That is a part that was a bit clunky, in what was otherwise a pretty decent and really enjoyable film. And oh yeah…that ending was so satisfying. It’s exactly how Dredd is in the comics as well. Which is why I loved it!😊
I can only hope that they will make a sequel in some form or other. There’s a tv show of this one in development hell for years now, and Karl Urban said himself that he wants to play the part again, so who knows🤞😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Fantastic review Michel. You’ve convinced me, especially as I’m a big fan of Urban!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you Kim! It’s a really well made film, with a pretty gritty storyline, but what really makes it work is Urban. I am too, he’s a really underrated actor in my opinion! 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
He’s brilliant in The Boys!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I hope the start with The Boys soon..maybe even this weekend 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yay!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m not as good as watching movies recently, but I really do love this film. It’s just so well put together, has so much that could happen later, and everything. Karl Urban is such a great actor too. I feel like I have to watch this one again.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You are so right Scott! I have seen it quite a few times now, and every time that I rewatch it, I really enjoy it! It’s a very compact but still highly entertaining film that doesn’t let up for even a single second! So yeah, good time to rewatch this! 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve seen the Stallone version but never heard of this one. Sounds like a much better film than the first which I found forgettable. Granted, I never read the comic. The Raid sounds familiar but I don’t think I’ve seen that one either. I think I’m remembering one where cops are infiltrating a high rise going after gangsters, but then… wait for it, you’ll never guess… the zombie outbreak starts and zombies begin taking over the high rise. Not a blockbuster, it was exactly what you’d expect but I think I recall enjoying it. I believe it was the 2009 French film, La Horde. You might enjoy it if you haven’t seen it, though I don’t know I’d rate it as highly as 9 out of 10, maybe 6 or 7. I’ve added Dredd to my queue.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Stallone version was really campy, and even though it had a much bigger budget, it was a mostly forgettable film.
This one though: really is like the comic: brutal, hard, and violent, but still with some great characters. And it’s Urban that steals the show.
If you like Asian martial arts films, I highly recommend the Raid. It’s a really great movie, and the second part is even better in my opinion😊 As for La Horde: I have seen it, I even have it on dvd!😀 It’s exactly as you say, not a 9 or 10…but a 7 definitely. Pretty bloody as well, but hey that’s usually the case with zombie films! 😊
I hope you will enjoy Dredd when you see it!😀
LikeLike
This is one of my favorite action movies, it goes straight to the point: ass kicking. I’m really enjoying your reviews, cheers.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha…that it does, doesn’t it? Pretty much all that you want from an action film, and it does that job tremendously well! That, and Urban is really good in this one! Thanks for your comment, and I’m very glad you are enjoying the reviews! More to come! 😀
LikeLike
I saw this at the cinema the day it came out, and I guess that expectation of ‘is this the next big thing?’ Worked against it…I should take another look, since I remember the character from 2000 AD. Like Pete, I do have a soft spot for the Stallone one!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I saw it in the cinema myself with my folks, but the first time I saw it, my mum wasn’t feeling very well that night so I didn’t get to enjoy it as much as I did with the second watch. But yeah, it’s definitely one that’s worth the rewatch😊 Some films become better with a second time. As for the Stallone film, I do too😀 As I mentioned it didn’t do well, but doesn’t mean that I myself didn’t like it. It was still campy fun, and it’s worth the watch for the visuals alone, as the world created in it was really good😊
This version though is much more in accordance with the comics😀
LikeLike
I got this movie for my father, and he enjoyed it. Only picked it up because it had a 3D version available, but I’m glad he liked it. Nice review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you! I saw it in the cinema back in the day when it was released so in the 3d version as well😀 It’s definitely a great film, and much better than it’s Stallone counterpart. Definitely recommend this one😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
I LOVE this version. Just wish Urban could have done more.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, there’s a lot of talk still going on for a tv series, but so far it’s just been talk. Urban wants to do it, but so far nobody has greenlit it. Real shame because as you say I really LOVED this version as well😀 It’s a great film, and highly underrated.
LikeLike
Good post!
I never saw the Stallone version but this one was good although I did see it after I saw The Raid, so for me it was a sci-fi version of that film, but fun nonetheless.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, I also saw the Raid before this one, and definitely found it had a lot of similarities. But well, it suited the character and I am a pretty big fan of the comic, so I definitely enjoyed myself 😀
The Stallone version is really different and quite campy. I enjoyed it, but this is absolutely the superior film 😊
LikeLike
i’m one of those who have put off watching this because of the Stallone version. I’ve never read the comics and am not a “fan”, so that movie is about all I have to judge the entire franchise by.
Sounds like I might need to check this out.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Definitely!😀 This is not even remotely similar to the Stallone version. It’s completely different, except for one thing the character is called Judge Dredd. That’s the only thing that’s the same lol😂
Seriously this is definitely a fun watch, and very gritty and dark. Hope you will enjoy this one when you see it!😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
“I am the law.” Dredd really does deserve more attention. I personally think it was the hard R rating that kept people from seeing it. Stallone’s Judge Dredd wasn’t good, but I’m not sure many people remembered it enough to write Dredd off for that reason. Not to mention Judge Dredd being more niche compared to the likes of Deadpool or Logan. Also as PG-13 as the 1995 movie seems, it actually was rated R. Dredd just used it far more effectively. I also hope a TV series or sequel gets made.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Could be that as well, or a combination of the two. Either way it was a really great and underrated movie. I enjoyed it quite a lot😀 As for the tv series…there has been talk about it for years now. Urban has been in talk with the creators of the series, but nothing so far has been confirmed. I think it’s one of those projects that just might end up in limbo for all eternity…but who knows, it can still happen I guess 🤞😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s definitely unfortunate that Stallone’s take on this character tarnished the franchise. You’ve definitely convinced me into fixing my lack of Dredd in my life by making sure that I go through his comics and movies before the end of 2021. I’ve always had a feeling that he’d be so much fun to explore, from the violence to the themes of justice. Thanks for sharing this with us! Excellent review as always, Michel! 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, Stallone’s take was weird but still fun in a weird kind of way lol.
This one though is so much better! I have couple of Dredd Omnibus editions still gathering dust, so I need to go and check those ones out as well! 🤔🤔 If only I had some more time 😊
LikeLike
I heard from someone that this iteration of Judge Dredd was inspired from another movie, The Raid. Not sure if it’s true. I haven’t watched this yet. But might soon! Awesome review.
LikeLike
Thank you 😊Yep, that’s true, I mentioned the Raid in my review😀
LikeLike
Sorry. 🤦♀️ i didn’t see it when I read your review.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha, no worries at all! 😀
LikeLike
It was actually the other way around, The Raid was inspired by Dredd’s original script when it was going around Hollywood, but it took so long for Dredd to come out that The Raid stole its thunder. Really, its like Dredd couldn’t catch an even break.
LikeLiked by 1 person
True, I read somewhere that parts of the script leaked out, and the Raid picked those parts up. Which is a real shame😢
LikeLike
Nice to hear you so positive on this, shall try to view it soon!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cool!😀 I hope you will enjoy it! As i said in my post, it’s a really underrated movie, that really is an incredibly fun watch!😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Dredd! I feel like Urban has had such a hard time finding movies that clicked with audiences and this really should have done better.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Couldn’t agree with you more! This movie was incredibly underrated and I loved it from start to finish. It has a really strong fanbase though and people have been trying for a long time now to get a sequel. So far no go though 😢
LikeLike
I remember watching this movie on tv & I actually liked it which is a bit of a surprise since it’s the complete opposite of everything I like in movies haha. I also didn’t know Lena Headey was Ma-Ma.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha, sometimes you watch something that you expect nothing from, either because it’s something you not normally watch, or because you’ve heard nothing good about it. This one really was terrific, both in terms of action, but also acting wise. As for Lena Headey, well to be fair she was almost unrecognisable in this movie, so that’s no surprise 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes I heard nothing about the movie before I watched it so it was suprisingly good haha
She does look completely different!
LikeLiked by 1 person
This movie is one of my favorite action movies. It’s gory, there’s so much action and it doesn’t force a romance between the two characters.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It really is an amazingly good movie. And so incredibly underrated. Karl Urban was awesome in this, and it has this really huge fan base, where we can only hope they are able to force a sequel at some point😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Fantastic movie this, really deserved a whole raft of sequels. I think the plan was to make bigger, more expensive and ambitious films as they went along, gathering pace. I think part of why it stumbled was that it came out during the 3D craze, and was put into cinemas with the higher ticket prices that came with 3D, putting people off going to see it. Had it just been released in 2D I’m certain it would have been more successful.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think that’s true, but also because the character of Dredd isn’t as well know as say Spiderman or characters like that. And people also remember Stallone’s take of this one, and that certainly didn’t help either (even though I still enjoyed that film for the campyness lol). There is still a tv series in the works, but it won’t have a focus on Dredd himself, and it’s not sure that Karl Urban will be attached to it. Then again that series has been in the works for so long not that I doubt if it will ever see the light of day.
LikeLike